Follow on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ScreenwritersSA
Screenwriter, prideful reviewer of others' work, and hopeful Redskins fan. And cracking into sitcoms and short scripts, too.
Re: reviews - Spend a lot of time with assignments. Hard copies of each script are printed, read thoroughly, notes scribbled all over the page with color coded highlighters (if necessary), then scan the script back into PDF format so the writer can review all notes with the feedback posted to Talentville. Writers are invited to email so their PDF script with notes can be shared. The typical Talentville review will include most important notes, a running list of spelling/grammar errors by page, and other notes not included in the edited PDF file (on a question & answer basis).
Furthermore, all ratings are provided so the writer can better understand which elements worked and which elements need more work.
Your honest feedback of the reviews is greatly appreciated since the purpose is to exceed expectations for each assignment.